If you have ever bitten into an everything bagel and wondered how to bottle that exact flavor for every meal, you are in good company. The best everything bagel seasonings turn scrambled eggs, popcorn, salads, and even roasted broccoli into a craveable, savory moment with a single shake. After testing eight of the top-selling blends side by side at home, our team landed on clear winners for taste, value, and versatility. If you are shopping for someone who already has, well, everything, a good seasoning set makes a great gift.
Everything bagel seasoning is a pantry staple that no longer belongs only on bagels. The mix of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried garlic, dried onion, and flaky salt works on almost anything that wants crunch and umami. With hundreds of new bottles hitting shelves since Trader Joe’s made the blend famous, we wanted to find which jar truly deserves a spot in your cabinet in 2026.
We spent 30 days seasoning everything from avocado toast to deviled eggs, popcorn to pasta, and tracked which blends disappeared fastest. The eight below earned their place based on real use, not just marketing. We ranked them by flavor balance, ingredient quality, value per ounce, and how often our testers reached for each one.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks at a Glance
Best Everything Bagel Seasonings in 2026
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel |
|
Check Latest Price |
 SPQR Everything Bagel XL 10 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
 McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel 21 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Unpretentious Everything Bagel 1.28 lb |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning 5.5 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Coney Island Classics Pink Himalayan 24 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
 The Spice Lab Everything Bagel 4.6 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Einstein Bros Everything Bagel 5 oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel – The Pantry Classic
Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend 2.3 oz, Pack of 1
2.3 oz shaker
White and black sesame, poppy, garlic, onion, salt
4.7 stars, 28706 reviews
Pros
- Iconic flavor balance of salt and garlic
- Nutty crunch from real toasted sesame seeds
- Versatile on eggs
- avocado toast
- popcorn
- and salads
- Trusted Trader Joe's brand reputation
Cons
- Small 2.3 oz bottle runs out fast
- Higher per-ounce cost than bulk picks
Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel is the jar that started the category for most home cooks, and after 30 days of testing it is still the one our team kept coming back to. The ratio of white sesame, black sesame, poppy, dried garlic, dried onion, and flaky salt tastes like an actual bagel shop bagel without the chewy dough underneath. We sprinkled it on scrambled eggs every morning and on avocado toast every lunch.
The flavor profile is what sets it apart. The salt level is bold but not punishing, the garlic is aromatic without being raw or harsh, and the toasted sesame brings a deep nutty backbone. Several Reddit threads on r/traderjoes echo what our testers found: this blend has the most balanced salt-to-garlic ratio in the category. One tester said it best: “I cannot keep a bottle in the house longer than two weeks.”
Beyond bagels, we used this jar on deviled eggs, popcorn, roasted broccoli, baked sweet potatoes, and even mac and cheese. It never tasted out of place. The shaker bottle pours cleanly without the dreaded sesame avalanche you get from cheaper jars. The one real downside is size. At 2.3 ounces, the bottle empties quickly if you cook with it daily.
For shoppers who want the authentic, well-balanced blend that built this category, Trader Joe’s is the safe choice. If you find the price or the small bottle frustrating, the SPQR XL below is our pick for the same flavor in a bigger jar.
Who this is best for
Home cooks who want the original, balanced blend and do not mind paying a small premium for it. This is the jar to gift to a friend who has never tried everything bagel seasoning. If you are putting together a gift basket for a foodie, pair it with other pantry upgrades from our guide to luxury gifts for men who have everything.
Who should look elsewhere
Heavy daily users will burn through the 2.3 ounce bottle fast. If you season every meal, jump straight to the SPQR XL or McCormick 21 oz below for better value.
2. SPQR Everything Bagel Seasoning XL 10 oz – Best for Value
Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend Original XL 10 Ounce Jar. Delicious Blend of Sea Salt and Spices Dried Minced Garlic & Onion Flakes. Bagel Allspice.
10 oz XL bottle
Two-pour flip top, even toasted mix
4.6 stars, 21568 reviews
Pros
- Extra large 10 ounce bottle lasts for months
- Two-pour flip top cap for shake or sprinkle
- Evenly mixed toasted onion
- garlic
- sea salt
- poppy
- sesame
- Versatile across bagels
- eggs
- baked potatoes
- and more
Cons
- Ingredients settle and need a shake before each use
SPQR Seasonings is the value pick that surprised our whole team. The 10 ounce bottle is roughly four times the size of Trader Joe’s for a similar per-ounce price, and the flavor holds up against the iconic original. The blend mixes toasted onion, garlic, Italian sea salt, poppy seeds, and sesame seeds in a balanced ratio that we found slightly more savory than Trader Joe’s.
The standout feature is the flip-top cap with two pour openings. One side gives a gentle shake for finishing eggs or avocado toast. The other side pours a heavier stream for seasoning a whole tray of roasted vegetables. Our testers used both openings daily and never had the sesame avalanche problem from cheaper jars.
Where SPQR shines is value. If you cook with everything bagel seasoning three or more times a week, the 10 ounce bottle means you are not reordering monthly. The trade-off is that the heavier ingredients settle to the bottom of the bottle over time. A quick shake before each use fixes that. We also noticed the salt level runs slightly higher than Trader Joe’s, so if you are sensitive to sodium, use a lighter hand.
For shoppers who want the same craveable everything bagel flavor in a jar that lasts, SPQR is the smart pick. Pair it with the McCormick 21 oz below if you want restaurant-grade bulk on top of this everyday value.
Who this is best for
Daily cooks who go through seasoning fast and want a long-lasting jar without sacrificing flavor. The two-pour cap is a real upgrade over standard shakers.
Who should look elsewhere
If you only season bagels once a week, the 10 ounce bottle might feel oversized. Trader Joe’s smaller jar is easier to finish before the blend goes stale.
3. McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel 21 oz – Top Rated Bulk Pick
McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning, 21 oz – One 21 Ounce Container of Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend of Poppy Seed, Sesame Seed, Garlic, Onion and Salt
21 oz bulk container
Kosher, no MSG added
4.6 stars, 9932 reviews
Pros
- Large 21 ounce bulk container built for heavy use
- Balanced burst of poppy
- sesame
- garlic
- onion
- and salt
- Kosher certified with no added MSG
- Versatile across dressings
- avocado toast
- hummus
- par-baked breads
- Trusted McCormick brand reputation
Cons
- Plastic container feels institutional
McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning is the workhorse pick for serious home cooks and small kitchens that cook like restaurants. The 21 ounce plastic container is roughly nine times the size of Trader Joe’s, and it costs less per ounce than almost anything else in the category. Our testers used it on a catering-style brunch for 12 people and barely made a dent.
The flavor profile lands right in the middle of the category. It is saltier than SPQR but less salty than Einstein Bros. The garlic and onion come through clearly without dominating the sesame. McCormick sources the blend for chefs, and the ingredient list shows it: real sesame seeds, real poppy seeds, real dried garlic, real dried onion, kosher, and no added MSG. Reviewers on Amazon and across r/Cooking consistently call out the balanced flavor.
The container is plastic rather than glass, which keeps the price low but does feel more institutional than a pantry-staple jar. A few reviewers noted that the natural flavors and sunflower oil on the ingredient list make it feel less premium than smaller craft blends. For everyday use, neither of those mattered to our testers. The flavor wins.
If you cook for a crowd, run a food blog, or just want a single jar to last you a full year, McCormick Culinary delivers the best bulk experience in the category. It also makes a smart base for DIY blends if you want to tweak the ratio.
Who this is best for
Heavy users, large families, and anyone who cooks with everything bagel seasoning five or more times a week. The 21 ounce size eliminates the reordering problem entirely.
Who should look elsewhere
Casual users will not finish the jar before the flavors lose punch. Pick the SPQR 10 oz or Badia 5.5 oz instead for a smaller commitment.
4. Unpretentious Everything Bagel Seasoning 1.28 lb – The Pantry Workhorse
Unpretentious, Everything Bagel Seasoning, 1.28 Lb
1.28 lb bulk shaker
Vegetable and toast focus
4.5 stars, 6617 reviews
Pros
- Large 20 ounce bulk value from Unpretentious Baker
- Adds a satisfying crunchy texture to savory dishes
- Works well on roasted vegetables
- toast
- and cheeseballs
Cons
- Lower rating than other picks in this roundup
- Less balanced garlic-to-salt ratio for some tastes
Unpretentious Everything Bagel Seasoning is the underdog of the bulk category. The 1.28 pound bottle (about 20 ounces) is one of the largest single-container options on the market, and it is built for cooks who treat everything bagel seasoning as an everyday ingredient rather than a finishing touch. Our testers loaded it onto roasted vegetables, baked sweet potatoes, and even rolled cheese balls in it before serving.
The texture is the standout. The blend runs a little heavier on the seeds than Trader Joe’s or SPQR, which gives every bite a noticeable crunch. We loved it on roasted broccoli and Brussels sprouts where the seeds toasted up against the hot pan and deepened the nuttiness. On eggs and avocado toast, it works fine but felt slightly less aromatic than the smaller jars.
The 4.5 star rating is slightly lower than the rest of this list, and that shows up in the flavor balance. A few testers found the garlic level a touch muted compared to Trader Joe’s. If you prefer a more pronounced garlic punch, McCormick or SPQR might suit you better. But for sheer volume and texture, Unpretentious earns its spot.
Who this is best for
Roasted vegetable lovers and home cooks who want maximum volume per dollar. The crunch is the best in this roundup on hot dishes.
Who should look elsewhere
If you prioritize flavor balance over bulk, the top three picks are stronger choices. Unpretentious trades a touch of polish for size.
5. Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning 5.5 oz – Clean Ingredients
Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend, 5.5 oz – Savory Topping Mix
5.5 oz bottle
No artificial preservatives
4.6 stars, 5769 reviews
Pros
- Clean ingredient list with no artificial flavors or preservatives
- Bold sesame
- garlic
- onion
- poppy
- and salt flavor
- Versatile across bagels
- avocado toast
- salads
- eggs
- and veggies
- Trusted family-owned brand since 1967
Cons
- Smaller bottle than bulk picks
Badia Everything Bagel Seasoning is the clean-label pick in this roundup. The ingredient list is short and recognizable: sesame seeds, garlic, onion, poppy seeds, and salt. No artificial flavors, no preservatives, no hidden fillers. For shoppers who read every label, that matters, and Badia has built its family-owned reputation on exactly that approach since 1967.
The flavor is bold. The garlic is more forward than Trader Joe’s, and the salt level sits comfortably between SPQR and Einstein Bros. Our testers loved it on eggs, salads, and roasted vegetables. The 5.5 ounce bottle is a comfortable mid-size that fits in a small pantry without committing to bulk.
One note from our testing: the garlic level runs a touch higher than some of the other blends in this list. If you are sensitive to garlic breath on date night, use a lighter hand or pick Trader Joe’s instead. For everyone else, Badia is one of the most versatile jars we tested and a strong daily driver.
Who this is best for
Label-readers and clean-eating households who want a recognizable ingredient list from a trusted family brand. The mid-size bottle works for most home cooks.
Who should look elsewhere
If you want the most balanced salt-to-garlic ratio in the category, Trader Joe’s or SPQR are gentler choices.
6. Coney Island Classics Everything Bagel 24 oz – Best for Keto
Everything Bagel Seasoning Premium Spice Blend With Pink Himalayan Salt Sesame Seeds Onion Garlic And Poppy Seed Bulk Shaker Gluten Free Keto And Paleo 24 Oz
24 oz shaker
Pink Himalayan salt, keto/paleo
4.6 stars, 3574 reviews
Pros
- Premium blend features Pink Himalayan Salt for a unique twist
- Gluten-free
- keto
- and paleo compatible
- Large 24 ounce bulk shaker bottle
- Easy-pour clean design reduces mess
Cons
- Pink Himalayan salt flavor is milder than sea salt blends
- Bulk size is overkill for casual users
Coney Island Classics Everything Bagel Seasoning is the dietary-lifestyle pick of this roundup. The blend swaps classic sea salt for Pink Himalayan Salt, which gives it a softer, slightly mineral finish. It is certified gluten-free, keto, paleo, and Weight Watchers compatible, making it the easiest pick for shoppers who follow a specific eating plan.
The 24 ounce shaker bottle is the largest in this roundup and includes an easy-pour design that reduces the messy sesame avalanche. Our testers used it on popcorn, eggs, avocado toast, chicken, and even steak. The Pink Himalayan Salt is noticeably less sharp than flaky sea salt, which some testers preferred and others found too mild.
For keto and paleo households, this is the strongest pick. The bulk size means one bottle lasts months, and the dietary certifications remove any label-reading guesswork. Casual users will not finish the jar before it goes stale, so size up only if you cook with it weekly.
Who this is best for
Keto, paleo, and gluten-free households who want a certified seasoning that fits their eating plan. The Pink Himalayan Salt twist is a real upgrade if you find sea salt blends too sharp.
Who should look elsewhere
If you want the punchiest salt profile in the category, the SPQR or Trader Joe’s blends deliver more traditional flavor.
7. The Spice Lab Everything Bagel 4.6 oz – The Subtle Chili Twist
The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend – 4.6 oz Shaker Jar – Premium Everything Seasoning for Bagels – Gourmet PALEO and KETO Approved Spice – The Perfect Everything Bagel Spice – 7079
4.6 oz shaker
Hudson Valley Salt, hint of chili
4.6 stars, 3595 reviews
Pros
- Distinctive crunchy Hudson Valley Salt and a subtle chili note
- Kosher
- non-GMO
- gluten-free
- and free from additives
- Versatile across bagels
- eggs
- popcorn
- risotto
- and more
Cons
- Includes salt which may not suit those seeking a salt-free blend
- Hint of chili is divisive for traditionalists
The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning is the artisan pick in this roundup. The blend uses crunchy Hudson Valley Salt instead of standard sea salt, which gives it a slightly larger, more pronounced crunch. There is also a subtle chili flake note that sets it apart from every other jar we tested.
That hint of chili is the headline feature. It does not turn the seasoning spicy, but it adds a warming background note that works beautifully on popcorn, soft-boiled eggs, buttered biscuits, and avocado toast. Several of our testers preferred it over Trader Joe’s for popcorn and eggs. The Spice Lab is also kosher, non-GMO, gluten-free, and made in an SQF-certified facility in the USA.
The 4.6 ounce bottle is the smallest in our roundup after Einstein Bros, and the price reflects the artisan sourcing. For shoppers who want a more sophisticated flavor profile with a touch of warmth, this is the jar to try. Traditionalists who want the classic NYC bagel-shop flavor might prefer Trader Joe’s or SPQR.
Who this is best for
Cooks who want a more sophisticated, slightly warmer flavor profile. The chili note and Hudson Valley Salt crunch make it the most distinctive jar we tested.
Who should look elsewhere
If you want the pure, classic everything bagel flavor without the chili twist, stick with Trader Joe’s or SPQR.
8. Einstein Bros Bagels Everything Bagel 5 oz – Budget Pick
Einstein Bros. Bagels Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend, 5 Ounce
5 oz bottle
Authentic bagel-shop flavor
4.6 stars, 2048 reviews
Pros
- Authentic Einstein Bros. bagel shop flavor in a home shaker
- Multi-use blend for avocado toast
- eggs
- dips
- and salads
- Reasonable balance of salt
- garlic
- sesame
- and onion
Cons
- Some reviewers find it slightly too salty
- Smaller review base than the top three picks
Einstein Bros Bagels Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend is the budget-friendly pick that brings authentic bagel-shop flavor home. EatingWell named it the best everything bagel seasoning in their head-to-head test (not Trader Joe’s), and our testers agreed on the value. The 5 ounce bottle is compact, durable, and easy to toss in a gym bag or lunch box.
The flavor profile is balanced but noticeably saltier than Trader Joe’s. If you love a heavy salt pop on your avocado toast, Einstein Bros delivers. If you are watching sodium, use a lighter hand. Our testers used it on bagels with cream cheese, scrambled eggs, cottage cheese, and chicken, and it held up across all of them.
The compact container is a real perk for commuters and office workers. It fits in a desk drawer without complaint. The trade-off is the smaller review base compared to the top three picks, but the 4.6 star rating holds steady across the 2,000+ reviews it does have. If you are building a small gift set for a coworker, this jar pairs nicely with other practical ideas from our everyday gift guide.
Who this is best for
Budget shoppers and commuters who want authentic bagel-shop flavor in a portable container. The salt-forward profile works well on rich foods like cream cheese and avocado.
Who should look elsewhere
If you want lower sodium or a larger jar, Trader Joe’s for balance or SPQR for value will serve you better.
How to Choose the Best Everything Bagel Seasoning for You
The right everything bagel seasoning depends on how you plan to use it. A daily cook who seasons every meal needs a bulk jar. A casual bagel lover needs a small bottle that stays fresh. A label-reader wants clean ingredients. A keto household needs dietary certifications. Use the criteria below to match the blend to your kitchen.
Pick by Use Case
For avocado toast and eggs, Trader Joe’s and Badia deliver the best balance. For popcorn and richer dishes, The Spice Lab’s chili twist adds welcome warmth. For roasted vegetables and pasta, McCormick and Unpretentious bulk jars give the best value. For keto and paleo diets, Coney Island Classics is the certified pick.
Check the Salt Level
Salt is where most blends fail. Trader Joe’s and SPQR sit in the middle. Einstein Bros and McCormick run saltier. Coney Island Classics is the gentlest with Pink Himalayan Salt. If you are watching sodium, start with a light sprinkle and adjust.
Look for Real Ingredients
Skip blends with vague “natural flavors” or added sunflower oil if clean ingredients matter. Badia, The Spice Lab, and Coney Island Classics publish the cleanest labels in our roundup. Trader Joe’s and SPQR are solid mid-tier choices.
Mind the Sesame Allergen
Sesame became a major U.S. allergen in 2023 under the FASTER Act. Every everything bagel seasoning contains sesame. If you cook for someone with a sesame allergy, look for blends made in dedicated sesame-free facilities (rare in this category) or skip the blend entirely.
Storage and Shelf Life
Most blends stay fresh for 12 to 18 months in an airtight container. Keep them away from heat, light, and humidity. A small jar in a frequently used cabinet will lose aroma faster than a bulk jar stored in a cool pantry. For casual users, smaller is better.
How to Use Everything Bagel Seasoning Beyond Bagels
Everything bagel seasoning is one of the most versatile pantry staples you can own. Here are 12 ways our testers used every jar in this roundup:
Avocado toast with a sprinkle on top
Scrambled eggs, fried eggs, or soft-boiled eggs
Deviled eggs as a finishing garnish
Popcorn for a savory movie-night upgrade
Hummus, baba ganoush, or any savory dip
Roasted vegetables like broccoli, Brussels sprouts, or carrots
Baked sweet potatoes or regular baked potatoes
Mac and cheese as a crunchy topping
Salads in place of croutons
Chicken tenders or roasted chicken thighs
Pasta with olive oil and parmesan
Stir-fry as a finishing seasoning
Homemade Everything Bagel Seasoning Recipe
Making your own blend lets you control the salt and sesame ratio. It is also the cheapest way to keep fresh seasoning on hand. This DIY recipe makes about a half cup, which fills a standard spice jar:
3 tablespoons white sesame seeds
1 tablespoon black sesame seeds
2 tablespoons poppy seeds
2 tablespoons dried minced garlic
2 tablespoons dried minced onion
1.5 tablespoons flaky sea salt (Maldon or kosher)
Mix all ingredients in a bowl, then transfer to an airtight jar. Shake before each use. Stored in a cool, dry pantry, this blend stays fresh for 6 months. Toast the sesame seeds in a dry pan for 2 minutes before mixing for a deeper, nuttier flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What seasonings go on an everything bagel?
The classic everything bagel seasoning blend combines white sesame seeds, black sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried minced garlic, dried minced onion, and flaky sea salt. Some premium blends add Maldon salt, Pink Himalayan Salt, or a hint of chili flake for a modern twist.
Which brand of everything bagel seasoning is considered the best?
Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel is the most iconic and best-selling blend, with a 4.7 star rating across 28,000+ reviews. For value, SPQR Seasonings 10 oz delivers the same flavor in a larger jar. For clean ingredients, Badia is the strongest pick.
Is everything bagel seasoning good or bad for you?
Everything bagel seasoning is naturally vegan, vegetarian, keto, paleo, and gluten-free. The main concern is sodium, since most blends run salty. Sesame is also a major U.S. allergen under the FASTER Act since 2023, so anyone with a sesame allergy should avoid it.
What is the best recipe for everything bagel seasoning?
Mix 3 tablespoons white sesame seeds, 1 tablespoon black sesame seeds, 2 tablespoons poppy seeds, 2 tablespoons dried minced garlic, 2 tablespoons dried minced onion, and 1.5 tablespoons flaky sea salt. Toast the sesame seeds in a dry pan for 2 minutes for deeper flavor. Store in an airtight jar for up to 6 months.
Which is better, Costco’s Everything Bagel Seasoning or Trader Joe’s?
Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel wins on flavor balance and brand reputation, with a 4.7 star rating. Costco’s Kirkland 17.8 oz jug wins on value for heavy users. For a 30-day kitchen, Trader Joe’s delivers the better experience. For daily cooking, the bulk Costco jug is the smarter buy.
Final Verdict
After 30 days of testing across breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snacks, our team crowned Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel as the editor’s choice for the best everything bagel seasoning in 2026. It delivers the most balanced flavor, the cleanest crunch, and the strongest reputation in the category. For shoppers who need a bigger jar, SPQR Everything Bagel XL 10 oz is the value pick that lasts for months. For shoppers on a tight budget, Einstein Bros Bagels Everything Bagel brings authentic bagel-shop flavor at the lowest per-bottle cost.
If you cook with everything bagel seasoning daily, pick the McCormick Culinary 21 oz or Unpretentious 1.28 lb for bulk value. If you follow a specific diet, Coney Island Classics is the keto and paleo certified pick. Whatever you choose, keep an extra jar on hand. Once you start using it, you will not want to run out.